More refugees were not created in communist Vietnam after the war, as Lind claims, than at any previous time; during the war, American bombing and the fighting on both sides created more than a million refugees. All communist regimes are not, as Lind believes, alike; it's absurd to equate the countless victims of Khmer Rouge genocide and of Maoism and Stalinism with the far fewer victims of Vietnamese land reform.
But then Lind gets his information on Vietnamese and Russian politics almost solely from defectors, who, with their special hatred and the angry sense of betrayal they carry into exile, are notoriously unstable and unreliable sources. Doan Van Thoi, a darling of the far right and Lind's main source, drew some headlines in the late '70s by convincing Joan Baez that the Vietnamese communists had slaughtered millions of victims after they took over in No Western journalist who stayed on after the takeover, nor any reputable historian since, has found evidence of such a bloodbath.
And the newly opened Soviet archives, which Lind depends on heavily, are a dubious source of information about Russian intentions and actions: Like FBI files and the Pentagon Papers, they're rife with raw misinformation and wishful thinking.
But the most bizarre of Lind's ideas is his concept of "losing well. Needless to say, there isn't a hint of the cost in human lives in Lind's flashy cost-benefit computations.
The Necessary War, Volume 1: Canadians Fighting The Second World War:1939-1943
Now that it's possible to travel and pursue research in Vietnam and Russia if not yet in China , it may finally be possible for a historian with a keen, compassionate intelligence to write a solid history of the war, taking into consideration who did what, when and why. Buy Now, Pay Later. Already a Subscriber? Log In Here. Please sign in with Facebook or Google below:. If you have an older Salon account, please enter your username and password below: sign in Forgot Password?
The Necessary War, Volume 1 - eBook - vesmocuahsioment.gq
Log Out. An unnecessary crock: Michael Lind's "Vietnam: The Necessary War" For some thinkers, that ol' international communist conspiracy will never die. Related Topics Books. Related Valerie Jarrett's leap of faith. Eve Ensler on men, MeToo and apologies.
Joy Reid: America can save itself. How Southern white women created Trump.
Previous Figure Next Figure. Email or Customer ID. Forgot password? Old Password. New Password. Password Changed Successfully Your password has been changed.
Log in to Wiley Online Library
Returning user. Request Username Can't sign in? The economic and political changes following that intense period at the end of the Eighteenth and the beginning of the Nineteenth century have been so extensive in their areas, and so vast in their statistical aggregates, that they almost baffle analysis and computation.
Out of that intense period there emerged the typical representative democracy that was destined within a century or more to become the prevailing form of political association among men. There emerged from that period the modern ideals of local, national, and international life, as swayed by the intelligence of the masses.
Invention and discovery also became recognized agents of social progress; and through these agents, within a century, the civilized nations had achieved an economic emancipation that was giving to the many what had been available to the privileged few alone in the Eighteenth Century. It has been true, however, of all historical progress, that conflicting influences are always present and that forward movements must fight their way, sometimes suffering retardation and temporary defeat. The leading minds of the American and French revolutions had a conception not merely of the rights of man as related to the government and growth of separate nations, but.
An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.
Related The Necessary War, Volume 1
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved